- Case Number: a20111004.1
- Status: closed
- Claimants: Peter F (aka Peter T)
- Respondents: CAcert
Initial Case Manager: BernhardFröhlich
Case Manager: EvaStöwe
former Case Manager: JoelHatsch
Arbitrator: MartinGummi
- Date of arbitration start: 2011-12-16
- Date of ruling: 2015-03-31
- Case closed: 2015-09-21
- Complaint: Assurer requests deletion of his account
- Relief: TBD
Before: Arbitrator Martin Gummi (A), Respondent: CAcert (R), Claimant: Peter F (C), Case: a20111004.1
History Log
2011-10-04 (issue.c.o) case s20111004.60
- 2011-10-07 (iCM): added to wiki, request for CM / A
2011-12-16 (CM): I'll take care of this case as (CM) and appoint MartinGummi as (A)
- 2011-12-16 (CM): Init email sent
2011-12-16 (CM): got notification about another running case for (C) (a20110319.1)
2013-09-16 (A of a20110319.1): case a20110319.1 dismissed, case closed.
2013-09-16 (A of a20110319.1): NDR received for 2nd email addr of (C), NDR forwarded to (CM of case a20111004.1), (A of case a20111004.1)
- 2013-11-01 (A): change CM
- 2013-11-02 (CM): Question to (Support) about activity and state of account
- 2013-11-02 (Support): Answer about state of account [s20131102.42]
- 2013-11-29 (A): sent mail to C to get in contact because of possible CAP-forms retrieval
- 2013-12-01 (C): I'll send CAPs if you provide me with pre-stamped envelope
- 2013-12-03 (A): we don't have much spare money for sending mails
- 2013-12-03 (C): want to keep CAPs for rest of period, does not want to keep email active, send post-address to be able to get contacted for the rest of the 7 years
- 2013-12-10 (CM): question to arbitration-list for ideas how to proceed
- 2013-12-15 (CM): question to support about implication of revocation of the assurances
- 2013-12-15 (Support): two assurees would drop below 50, one down to 0 points
- 2014-02-12 (CM): asks support if some members are assurer as they had given their ok to help
- 2014-02-12 (Support): according members are no assurer at the moment
- 2014-03-24 (A): asks AS1 if he would help with the gathering of the CAP forms
- 2014-06-02 (CM): sends reminder to AS1
- 2014-06-03 (AS1): aggrees to the process and provides his address
- 2014-09-14 (A): asks C if it would be acceptable to send the CAP forms to an assurer from his own country
- 2014-09-16 (C): would accept this if address would be provided in a mail signed by a certificate issued by another CA than CAcert
- 2014-10-02 (A): add support ticket s20140925.7524
- 2015-03-31 (A): ruling and execution request send to C, Support and CM
- 2015-09-21 (CM): informs A that the case will be closed; thanks A for his work
- 2015-09-21 (CM): closes case
Original Dispute, Discovery (Private Part) (optional)
Link to Arbitration case a20111004.1 (Private Part), Access for (CM) + (A) only)
EOT Private Part
Discovery
There's another arbitration case concerning the Claimant: a20110319.1
According to a20110319.1 the Claimant is an Assurer and has given Assurances
- DRP 2.2 Preliminaries : "Participating Users may not resign until the completion of the case."
- Case put on hold until other case completed
- The claimant wants to get his account closed. He is an assurer with given assurances that are not 7 years old. He did refuse to provide the CAP form in an acceptable way to the Arbitrator or another assurer.
- The account has at least one certificate that needs to be revoked.
Ruling
The account of the claimant should be closed by Support analogue to the process of a20111128.3 as soon as possible. According to the ruling given in a20141231.1 there is no need to collect the CAP forms. Also the assurances given by the claimant should not be revoked.
-- Lübeck, 2015-03-31
Execution
- 2015-03-31 (A): ruling and execution request send to C, Support and CM
- 2015-03-31 (C): thanks A for ruling, considers this to be a wise decision, remebers some discussion, asks if he just can keep the CAP forms or if he should discard them
- 2015-04-01 (Support): cannot find account with given email address and given name
- 2015-04-01 (A): provides other name and explains confusion to be reason of a name change that was performed
- 2015-04-01 (Support): execution confirmation
- 2015-04-01 (Support): explains parts of the ruling to C - gives room for A to add additional answer
- 2015-09-21 (CM): informs A that the case will be closed; thanks A for his work
- 2015-09-21 (CM): closes case
Similiar Cases