• Arbitrations
• a20090518.1

• Case Number: a20090518.1
• Status: closed
• Claimants: dirk astrath
• Respondents: Robert Cruikshank

• Case Manager: Alejandro Mery, UlrichSchroeter as substitute

• Arbitrator: TBA
• former Arbitrator: Sebastian Küppers
• Date of arbitration init: 2009-05-18
• Date of arbitration starts: ?
• Date of arbitration ruling:
• Date of arbitration execution:
• Date of arbitration close: 2009-12-25
• Complaint: People is getting 150 points from TTP while the programme is frozen

Against what mandated in the AP people is still getting 150 points from the TTP programme which is (in theory) frozen until we get a sub-policy, and when it was supposed to be limited to 100 points.

• Relief: XXX/None

Before: Arbitrator name arbitor (A), Respondent: Robert Cruikshank (R), Claimant: dirk astrath (C), Case: a20090518.1

History Log

• 2009-10-12 (CM): UlrichSchroeter step-in as substitute

• 2009-10-12 (CM): request for actual state from before CM, A (init mails sent?)
• 2009-11-13 (CM): no answer from old (CM), no answer from (A), no answer from (C), no answer from (R)
• 2009-11-14 (CM): re-request infos from old (CM) and (A), awaiting reply till Sun 22, 2009
• 2009-11-14 (CM): sending initial mail to (C) and (R), awaiting reply till Sun 22, 2009
• 2009-11-15 (CM): reply from old (CM), no special info, except 'move on'

• 2009-12-25 (UlrichSchroeter): arbitrator released this case as of a20091118.4

• 2009-12-25 (CM): merge to arbitration case a20091118.1

• 2009-12-25 (CM): this case closed.

Discovery

Timeline of Policy Descisions and Motions

• 2008-07-12 p20080712.1 Assurance Policy

  • Proposal for Assurance Policy to move from WIP to DRAFT status.
  • Votes: 9 Ayes, 1 Nay, 4 Abstentions.

• 2009-01-05 p20090105.2 Assurance Policy status: POLICY

  • Proposal to accept Assurance Policy as POLICY has been voted on. Votes ended 24th of December 2008.
  • AYE: 5 - Nay: 0
  • (AP is now on main website.)

• 2009-09-12 m20090912.1 - m20090912.1

  • Approved 2009-09-20 00:00:03 UTC m20090912.1
  • Assurance under Assurance Policy only
  • Resolved, that this committee, officers and all Assurers are charged to
  • ensure that all assurance follows Assurance Policy, made binding DRAFT
  • p20080712.1 and POLICY p20090105.2.
  • Further resolved, to cease all assurance activity outside Assurance
  • Policy. Old programmes not as yet translated into the new Assurance Policy
  • regime of subsidiary policies include:
  • - super-assurance
  • - TVerify
  • - assurances by and of Juniors
  • - TTP
  • These are to cease immediately, and be only restarted when the appropriate
  • subsidiary policy under AP is passed into DRAFT by policy group.
  • This committee notes with concern that any assurance conducted outside AP
  • (after its passing into binding DRAFT) is subject to reversal and worse by
  • the Arbitrator.
  • Due: 2009-09-19 23:59:59 UTC
  • Proposed: Ian Grigg (2009-09-12 13:44:44 UTC)
  • Vote type: veto
  • Aye|Naye|Abstain: 5|0|0

• 2009-09-14 m20090914.2 - Confirm Motion m20090912.1

• 2009-09-28 m20090928.1 - Tverify continues till Nov 16, 2009

  • Approved 2009-10-06 00:00:02 UTC m20090928.1
  • Run Tverify as-is until End Of Life 20091116
  • Aye|Naye|Abstain: 6|1|0

Technical

• Database Structure and Fields that relates to Special Assurance Programs

• as defined under Database Structure

  • Notary: This table contains all data for events which award Trust Points: Assurances, TTP, Thawte Point transfers etc.
  • Cats_Passed: Lists all the tests passed by a user.
  • TVerify: ?
  • TVerify-Vote: ?
  • Users: Contains one record for each registered user.
    • parameters that probably relates to special assurance programs

Ruling

Execution

Similiar Cases

• CategoryArbitration

• CategoryArbCaseOtherAssurerErrors