* Case Number: a20090518.1
    * Status: closed
    * Claimants: dirk astrath
    * Respondents: Robert Cruikshank
    * Case Manager: Alejandro Mery, UlrichSchroeter as substitute
    * Arbitrator: TBA
    * former Arbitrator: Sebastian Küppers
    * Date of arbitration init: 2009-05-18
    * Date of arbitration starts: ?
    * Date of arbitration ruling:
    * Date of arbitration execution:
    * Date of arbitration close: 2009-12-25
    * Complaint: People is getting 150 points from TTP while the programme is frozen

{{{
Against what mandated in the AP people is still getting 150 points from the TTP programme which is (in theory) frozen until we get a sub-policy, and when it was supposed to be limited to 100 points.
}}}

    * Relief: XXX/None

Before: Arbitrator name arbitor (A), Respondent: Robert Cruikshank (R), Claimant: dirk astrath (C), Case: a20090518.1

== History Log ==
 . 2009-10-12 (CM): UlrichSchroeter step-in as substitute
 . 2009-10-12 (CM): request for actual state from before CM, A (init mails sent?)
 . 2009-11-13 (CM): no answer from old (CM), no answer from (A), no answer from (C), no answer from (R)
 . 2009-11-14 (CM): re-request infos from old (CM) and (A), awaiting reply till Sun 22, 2009
 . 2009-11-14 (CM): sending initial mail to (C) and (R), awaiting reply till Sun 22, 2009
 . 2009-11-15 (CM): reply from old (CM), no special info, except 'move on'
 . 2009-12-25 (UlrichSchroeter): arbitrator released this case as of [[Arbitrations/a20091118.4|a20091118.4]]
 . 2009-12-25 (CM): merge to arbitration case [[Arbitrations/a20091118.1|a20091118.1]]
 . 2009-12-25 (CM): this case closed.

== Discovery ==
=== Timeline of Policy Descisions and Motions ===
 * 2008-07-12 [[PolicyDecisions#p20080712.1_Assurance_Policy|p20080712.1]] Assurance Policy
  . Proposal for Assurance Policy to move from WIP to DRAFT status.
  . Votes: 9 Ayes, 1 Nay, 4 Abstentions.

 * 2009-01-05 [[PolicyDecisions#p20090105.2_Assurance_Policy_status:_POLICY|p20090105.2]] Assurance Policy status: POLICY
  . Proposal to accept Assurance Policy as POLICY has been voted on. Votes ended 24th of December 2008.
  . AYE: 5 - Nay: 0
  . (AP is now on main website.)

 * 2009-09-12 [[https://community.cacert.org/board/motions.php?motion=m20090912.1|m20090912.1]] - m20090912.1
  . Approved 2009-09-20 00:00:03 UTC m20090912.1
  . Assurance under Assurance Policy only
  . Resolved, that this committee, officers and all Assurers are charged to
  . ensure that all assurance follows Assurance Policy, made binding DRAFT
  . p20080712.1 and POLICY p20090105.2.
  . Further resolved, to cease all assurance activity outside Assurance
  . Policy.  Old programmes not as yet translated into the new Assurance Policy
  . regime of subsidiary policies include:
  . - super-assurance
  . - TVerify
  . - assurances by and of Juniors
  . - TTP
  . These are to cease immediately, and be only restarted when the appropriate
  . subsidiary policy under AP is passed into DRAFT by policy group.

  . This committee notes with concern that any assurance conducted outside AP
  . (after its passing into binding DRAFT) is subject to reversal and worse by
  . the Arbitrator.
  . Due: 2009-09-19 23:59:59 UTC
  . Proposed: Ian Grigg (2009-09-12 13:44:44 UTC)
  . Vote type: veto
  . Aye|Naye|Abstain: 5|0|0

 * 2009-09-14 [[https://community.cacert.org/board/motions.php?motion=m20090914.2|m20090914.2]] - Confirm Motion m20090912.1

 * 2009-09-28 [[https://community.cacert.org/board/motions.php?motion=m20090928.1|m20090928.1]] - Tverify continues till Nov 16, 2009
  . Approved 2009-10-06 00:00:02 UTC m20090928.1
  . Run Tverify as-is until End Of Life 20091116
  . Aye|Naye|Abstain: 6|1|0

=== Technical ===
 * Database Structure and Fields that relates to Special Assurance Programs
 . as defined under [[Software/Database/StructureDefined|Database Structure]]
  * Notary: This table contains all data for events which award Trust Points: Assurances, TTP, Thawte Point transfers etc. 
  * Cats_Passed: Lists all the tests passed by a user. 
  * TVerify: ?
  * TVerify-Vote: ?
  * Users: Contains one record for each registered user.
   . parameters that probably relates to special assurance programs
|| codesign || int(1) || 1 if allowed to request code signing certs ||
|| 1024bit || tinyint(1) || ? ||
|| admin || tinyint(1) || 1 if user is admin ||
|| ttpadmin || tinyint(1) || 1 if user is TTP admin ||
|| orgadmin || tinyint(1) || 1 if user is Org admin ||
|| board || tinyint(1) || 1 if user is member of CAcert's board (?) ||
|| tverify || tinyint(1) || 1 if user is tverify admin (?) ||
|| locadmin || tinyint(1) || 1 if user can administer the location database ||
|| assurer || int(2) || 1 if user is Assurer (100 Assurance Points plus Challenge). This field is caching only, if performance does not forbid try to select the underlying data instead. ||
|| assurer_blocked || tinyint(1) || 1 if user may not become assurer ||


== Ruling ==

== Execution ==

== Similiar Cases ==
|| [[Arbitrations/a20091118.1|a20091118.1]] || [[Arbitrations/a20091118.1|Assurances while TTP program frozen]] ||

----
 . CategoryArbitration
 . CategoryArbCaseOtherAssurerErrors